Not every risky investment is a scam, but every scam looks like a good investment at first. This article is a practical checklist of warning signs worth pausing on before directing IRA funds into any specific opportunity — real estate, private equity, a promissory note, or anything else.
Steps / Explanation
Returns and pressure
Guaranteed, unusually high, or "risk-free" returns. Every legitimate investment carries some risk of loss. A guarantee, or a return far above what comparable investments offer, is worth independent scrutiny.
Urgency to act immediately. Genuine opportunities can typically withstand a few days of due diligence. Heavy pressure to decide "today" is designed to stop you from checking the details.
Secrecy or exclusivity framing. Be cautious of pitches that discourage you from discussing the opportunity with a tax advisor, attorney, or anyone else before committing.
Documentation and transparency
No independent way to verify value. You should be able to point to something outside the promoter's own claims — an appraisal, a title report, audited financials, a public filing — that supports the stated value. This also matters later: see "What is fair market valuation (FMV) and why it matters" for how that value gets reported annually.
No written offering documents. Legitimate private investments typically come with some form of written documentation (an operating agreement, a subscription agreement, a private placement memorandum). Reluctance to provide anything in writing is a warning sign.
Vague or evasive answers to basic questions. You should be able to get a straight answer to questions like "how is my money being used," "what happens if this fails," and "how do I get my money back out."
Structure and parties involved
Involvement of a disqualified person. If the opportunity connects back to you, your spouse, a family member, or an entity one of you controls, it may create a prohibited transaction rather than a legitimate investment. See "Disqualified persons — who counts and why" and "Prohibited transactions — what they are and why they matter."
Unregistered promoters or securities. Check whether the person or the offering is registered with the SEC or a state securities regulator, where registration would normally be required.
No clear exit path. Understand upfront how and when you'd be able to get funds back out, and what could delay or prevent that.
Process
Requests to pay outside the standard account process. Funding a legitimate SDIRA investment flows through Digital Trust's custodial process and the documentation described in "Your recordkeeping responsibilities as an SDIRA holder." A request to send funds directly to an individual, or to skip that documentation, is a red flag regardless of how legitimate the opportunity otherwise looks.
Pressure to skip or inflate valuation reporting. Any suggestion that you should under-report, over-report, or skip fair market valuation reporting altogether is a serious warning sign, independent of whether the underlying investment is legitimate.
What to do when you spot a red flag
Pause before proceeding. Ask for documentation, verify it independently where you can, and give yourself time to think it through. We recommend consulting a tax advisor or attorney for guidance specific to your situation — neither Retired.com nor Digital Trust, our custodian, evaluates or advises on the suitability of any investment. If something about the request itself (not just the investment) looks like fraud, see "How to spot IRA investment scams" and contact the Service Team.
Common questions
Does having some of these red flags always mean an investment is a scam?
Not necessarily — some legitimate investments are genuinely higher-risk or less liquid. But the more red flags present, and the more a promoter resists answering questions about them, the more caution is warranted.
Who can help me evaluate a specific opportunity?
Retired.com and Digital Trust don't evaluate or recommend investments. An independent tax advisor, attorney, or other qualified professional is the right resource for a specific opportunity.
Is there a checklist I can use every time?
This article covers the core categories — returns/pressure, documentation, structure, and process. Working through each category for any new opportunity is a reasonable standard practice.
Need more support? Contact our Service team
Select "Start a Conversation" from the Chat menu or call us at 1-800-RETIRED